Can Information Powers Expose a Journalist’s Confidential Sources?

A confidential source often starts an investigation.

Information about corruption, financial misconduct, administrative irregularities or corporate wrongdoing may reach journalists through employees, officials, whistleblowers and people who do not want to reveal their identities.

For many of these people confidentiality is not just convenient. Confidentiality is a condition that allows them to share information.

The Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023 raises a question: can statutory information‑gathering powers expose the identity of a journalists confidential sources?

This issue deserves attention because protecting journalistic sources is closely linked to the freedom of the press under Article 19(1)(a).

Why are confidential sources important?

Investigative journalism often depends on information that cannot be found in press releases or public documents.

An employee may disclose evidence of irregularities inside an organisation. A government officer may share documents that reveal irregularities in a public procurement process. A whistleblower may provide communications that show wrongdoing.

In each situation a confidential source may face consequences, retaliation or even threats to personal safety if the confidential source’s identity becomes known.

If a confidential source believes that the source’s identity can be easily discovered through legal or administrative processes the confidential source may stop sharing information.

The harm extends beyond the journalist. It can stop the public from learning about matters that’re truly important.

Section 36 of the DPDP Act: The power to call for information

Section 36 gives the Central Government the power to call for information from a Data Fiduciary or intermediary when the Government thinks it is necessary for specified purposes.

These purposes include the use of data by the State or its instrumentalities and the fulfilment of obligations under the Act.

The provision also has restrictions on disclosing information that could affect the sovereignty and integrity of India, the security of the State relations with foreign States, public order or the prevention of incitement to cognisable offences.

The existence of this power raises questions about how it applies to information kept by news organisations.

A newsroom may store data about sources, communications, research notes, interview records and unpublished material.

Depending on the circumstances some of this information may identify a source.

The concern is whether an exercised information‑gathering power could indirectly expose the identities of confidential sources.

Does Section 36 authorise disclosure of every journalistic record?

No.

It would be wrong to suggest that Section 36 automatically gives the Government access to every newsroom record or confidential communication.

The power must be exercised within the framework and for the purposes specified by the provision.

However the lack of a comprehensive journalistic‑source protection in the DPDP framework creates a real concern about the safeguards for such requests.

The constitutional issue is not just whether the Government can seek information. It is whether the scope, necessity, authorisation and review of requests are clearly defined to protect journalistic independence.

The absence of an exemption makes the issue more serious

The concern becomes more serious when Section 36 is looked at together with the lack of a specific journalistic exemption.

If news organisations are treated as Data Fiduciaries for processing activities their information systems may hold records about identifiable individuals.

The question then is whether the Government’s information‑gathering power could reach material that reveals the identity of sources or the confidential nature of an investigation.

This concern has been raised in the challenges before the Supreme Court.

The Reporters Collective petition, among issues questions the breadth of Section 36 and its possible implications for investigative journalism and confidential sources.

Explained News. The Express+1

What does constitutional law say about source protection?

The Supreme Court has repeatedly recognised the importance of freedom of the press.

In Indian Express Newspapers v. Union of India (1985) 1 SCC 641 the Court acknowledged that a free press is important in a society.

In Sakal Papers (P) Ltd. V. Union of India AIR 1962 SC 305 and Bennett Coleman & Co. V. Union of India (1972) 2 SCC 788 the Court examined restrictions that affect the functioning of newspapers through the protection of freedom of speech and expression.

These decisions give the basis, for examining measures that may indirectly interfere with the ability of journalists to gather and publish information.

However it is important to recognise that Indian law does not give a absolute journalist‑source privilege that overrides every lawful investigation or judicial process.

Source confidentiality must be considered within the context of the law and the constitutional rights involved.

What safeguards should exist?

Any legal power that gathers information about material must be paired with clear procedural safeguards.

A balanced framework should consider:

  1. Necessity: The authority must show why the requested information is truly needed.
  2. Proportionality: A request must not cover a newsroom database when only specific information is enough.
  3. Independent scrutiny: Requests that involve journalistic sources must be examined independently before any disclosure.
  4. Protection of source identity: Information that can identify a source must receive stronger protection.
  5. Purpose limitation: Information that is obtained must not be used for any purpose that is not related to the objective for which it was sought.
  6. Review mechanism: The organisation that is affected must have access to a process to challenge any request that is excessive or unlawful while respecting legitimate confidentiality requirements.

These safeguards do not stop investigations. They make sure that information‑gathering powers are exercised responsibly.

Why does this matter beyond journalism?

The protection of sources is also important for whistleblowing, corporate governance and public accountability.

A person who exposes fraud or corruption may have information that cannot be found through ordinary channels.

If the legal framework does not protect the confidentiality of disclosures well enough the flow of information may decrease.

This could affect not media organisations but also regulators, civil society institutions and the public.

Section 36 raises a question about the relationship between State information‑gathering powers and the independence of the press.

The Government must keep the ability to obtain information where the law legitimately allows it. However those powers must not become a way to unnecessarily identify journalistic sources.

A democratic legal system must recognise that protecting a source can sometimes be essential, to protecting the publics right to know.

The ultimate test is whether the law offers safeguards to make sure that legitimate information‑gathering powers do not undermine the constitutional freedom that they are expected to coexist with.