A newspaper report that was first published ten years ago can still show up in Google search results today. That report might be about an investigation, a corporate dispute, a government official or an individual who once found themselves in a public controversy.
The report may have been accurate at the time it was published. However the individual concerned may now argue that the continued availability of the article harms their privacy, reputation or professional life.
This raises a question under the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023. I notice that this is an issue. Can the continued storage, indexing and display of a news report be considered the processing of personal data?
Answering this question means we must distinguish between publication, archival preservation and the later use of information by platforms.
What qualifies as data?
Section 2 of the DPDP Act defines personal data as data about an individual who is identifiable by or in relation to that data.
A news article that contains an individuals name, photograph, professional details, statements or personal history can therefore contain data.
The fact that the information has already entered the domain does not automatically mean that personal data ceases to exist.
For example a digital news article that identifies a company director in connection with an investigation may contain personal data even when the investigation and related proceedings were reported publicly.
Similarly a historical article that concerns an individual convicted of an offence may continue to contain personal data long after the criminal proceedings have concluded.
The relevant question is not whether the information is publicly accessible. The relevant question is whether the information relates to an individual and is being processed within the scope of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023. I think the key is to see whether the information really belongs to a person.
Is maintaining a news archive a form of processing?
The Digital Personal Data Protection Act defines processing
Processing includes automated operations such as collection, storage organisation, structuring, retrieval, use, sharing, dissemination and erasure of personal data.
Consequently maintaining a news archive may involve processing personal data. I think this is a point.
Consider a publisher that maintains a database of articles published over the last twenty years.
The publisher may continue to store articles organise them by date and subject maintain search functionality and display results when readers search for a particular individual.
These activities involve operations that may qualify as processing under the definition.
The fact that an article was originally published years ago does not necessarily take its continued storage and retrieval outside the statutory framework.
Does the public availability of information create an exemption?
This is a distinction.
Section 3(c) of the DPDP Act excludes categories of personal data from its application. Those categories include data that is made or caused to be made publicly available by:
– The Data Principal to whom the personal data relates; or
– Any other person who is under an obligation under any law in force in India to make such personal data publicly available.
However this is not a blanket exemption for every item of information that can be found on the internet. I find that this exemption is not always clear.
For example if a person voluntarily publishes their professional information on a public website the statutory exclusion may become relevant.
Likewise personal data made available pursuant to a legal obligation may fall within the exclusion.
A newspaper publishing personal data about an individual does not automatically establish that the individual made that personal data public.
Does every historical court report or news article necessarily fall within the second category.
The precise circumstances in which personal data became public must be examined.
What happens when an individual requests removal of an article?
Imagine that a person was accused of financial misconduct in 2012. The newspaper published a report based on the information at that time.
In 2018 the person was discharged by a court. However the original article remains accessible online. Continues to appear in search results.
The individual approaches the publisher seeking deletion of the article.
Several legal considerations arise.
First the publisher must examine whether the original publication was lawful and whether the article accurately reflected the proceedings at the time.
Second the publisher should distinguish between removing an article and updating it with developments.
Third the publisher must examine the nature of the request and the legal rights available to the individual.
Fourth the publisher must consider the importance of preserving a historical record.
The right to seek correction or erasure under the DPDP Act must be examined alongside the statutory conditions, exceptions and commencement provisions.
It should not be assumed that every request for deletion automatically requires the removal of a published news report. I hope that this clarification helps.
The distinction, between publishers and search engines
Another difficulty appears when the article can be found on both the publishers website and on a search engine.
The publisher keeps the article. The search engine may separately crawl, index organise. Display information from the article.
These are distinct processing activities carried out by different entities.
A request aimed at the publisher to remove or update the article is therefore not necessarily the same as a request aimed at the search engine concerning its search results.
This distinction is important when assessing responsibility grounds for processing and the appropriate remedy.
A person may seek correction of an article, removal of an unlawful disclosure or a restriction on the appearance of particular search results. Each request may require a legal analysis.
What about the right to be forgotten?
The right to be forgotten has developed in the context of privacy and informational autonomy.
In K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017) 10 SCC 1 the Supreme Court recognised the right to privacy including informational privacy.
The Delhi High Court has also examined the issue in cases such as Jorawar Singh Mundy v. Union of India 2021 SCC OnLine Del 2306 involving the removal of a judgment from search results.
However the right to privacy does not automatically translate into a right to erase every historical publication.
There must be an assessment of the individuals privacy interests the accuracy and nature of the information the passage of time and the public interest in availability.
A historical report concerning corruption for example may have continuing public significance even after several years.
On the hand unnecessary circulation of inaccurate, outdated or disproportionately intrusive personal information may justify corrective action.
What should digital publishers do?
News organisations should consider developing a policy for handling requests concerning archived content.
Such a policy should distinguish between:
1. Incorrect factual information requiring correction.
2. Subsequent developments requiring an update.
3. Unlawful or unnecessarily intrusive disclosures.
4. Requests for removal of accurate reporting.
5. Search-engine. Independent third-party processing.
A publisher should also maintain editorial records explaining why the article has been retained, updated or modified.
This will help demonstrate that decisions are based on considerations and applicable legal requirements rather than arbitrary removal requests.
Conclusion
Digital news archives are a part of the public record. They preserve reporting, support accountability and allow citizens to understand how institutions and individuals have acted over time.
At the time the continued digital availability of personal information can affect individual privacy in ways that were not always foreseeable when the original article was published.
The DPDP framework makes it necessary to examine the processing involved in maintaining organising and retrieving news content.
The appropriate solution is not to make historical journalism immune from accountability or to permit every individual to erase reporting.
Instead the law must recognise the difference, between correcting information protecting legitimate privacy interests and removing accurate reporting that continues to serve a public purpose.
The central question is not simply whether an old news article contains data. It is whether the continued processing and availability of that information remains legally justified and proportionate.
News Archives, Search Results and DPDP: Can a Published Story Become Personal-Data Processing?



