Journalistic Exemption under the DPDP Act: What Is Missing from the Statute?

The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 was introduced to create a framework that protects digital personal data in India. Yet one important omission has drawn criticism from journalists, publishers and media organisations. That omission is the lack of an exemption for journalistic activities.

This omission matters because journalism and data protection often work together in the area. A journalist who investigates fraud looks at government records or reports on corporate misconduct may need to gather and handle personal information without asking the people involved for consent.

The question is whether the statutory framework recognises this reality.

What does the DPDP Act actually regulate?

The DPDP Act applies to the processing of personal data that occurs inside India. It also covers some processing that happens outside India depending on the conditions.

The term personal data means information about an individual who can be identified by or through data.

Consequently information that a journalist gathers during an investigation can become data even if that information concerns professional conduct, public office or commercial activities.

For example think of a journalist who investigates a government officer who is suspected of awarding contracts to a related company. That investigation may involve details, financial records, communications and corporate relationships.

The fact that the information is collected for publication does not on its own take it out of the definition of data.

Why is a journalistic exemption necessary?

Ordinary data processing and journalistic data processing aim at objectives.

A business that collects customer information usually wants to provide a service, market products or improve operations. Journalism on the hand may need to gather information to expose wrongdoing verify public claims or inform citizens.

The requirement for consent can create difficulties.

A journalist who investigates an official cannot be expected to get that officials consent before examining information that matters to the investigation.

Similarly a journalist who investigates an investment scheme cannot ask the alleged perpetrators for permission before collecting and checking relevant information.

If consent becomes a precondition for such processing the person being investigated may gain the power to obstruct the investigation.

What exemptions does Section 17 provide?

Section 17 gives exemptions from some parts of the DPDP Act in circumstances.

For example Section 17(2)(a) covers processing that’s necessary for research, archiving or statistical purposes, subject to the conditions set out.

However this provision is not an exemption for journalistic purposes.

Similarly exemptions that relate to rights, judicial functions and some State activities are limited to the circumstances that the statute specifies.

The DPDP Act does not specifically create an exemption for collecting, verifying, storing and publishing personal data that is done for genuine journalism.

This is the gap that is at the centre of the debate.

It is also important to separate the fact that an exemption exists in the law from the time it begins. The notification dated 13 November 2025 says that Section 17 will start eighteen months after publication, which’s in May 2027.

The compliance dilemma for news organisations

Consider a news publisher who keeps an investigative report about a company director who is accused of financial irregularities.

The publisher may have gathered the directors name, professional history, corporate associations, financial information and statements from employees.

The information may be needed to prove the report.

Under the framework of the DPDP Act a Data Fiduciary must meet obligations about lawful processing, notice, consent or recognized legitimate uses security safeguards and erasure.

The lack of a journalism- exemption creates uncertainty about how these obligations apply to investigative reporting.

There is another difficulty.

Suppose the person who is the subject of a published investigation later asks for the erasure of data. The publisher may have to think about that request under the law. Deleting the underlying information could harm the preservation of news archives and the ability to verify old reporting.

This is why the exemption must cover more, than publication. It must also recognise the steps that are needed to produce and preserve journalism.

What should a drafted exemption contain?

A meaningful exemption should be carefully structured of absolute.

First it should cover journalistic activity that is done to inform the public investigate matters that matter to the public and spread news and commentary.

Second it should extend to collecting, verifying, analysing, storing and publishing data when those activities are reasonably needed for journalism.

Third it should recognise how important confidential sources are and protect information that could identify them following the law and only in defined exceptions.

Fourth I think the policy should care about keeping published material and news archives. A request for erasure should not automatically remove historical reporting.

Fifth the journalistic exemption should not become a licence for media organisations to misuse information. Unrelated commercial exploitation, surveillance, malicious disclosure and unnecessary publication of sensitive information should remain under proper safeguards.

I see that a public-interest test, need and fairness requirements, responsibility and outside review could help achieve this balance.

The constitutional dimension

I think Article 19(1)(a) protects freedom of speech and expression. The freedom of the press although not separately listed in the Constitution forms a core part of this guarantee.

In Indian Express Newspapers v. Union of India (1985) 1 SCC 641 the Supreme Court recognised the importance of press freedom.

I believe the absence of an exemption must therefore be examined against the practical consequences for the exercise of that freedom.

The question is not whether journalists should be exempt from every law. They should not. The question is whether a general data protection framework should impose obligations without accounting for the distinct requirements of public-interest reporting.

Conclusion

The DPDP Act seeks to protect individuals against misuse of data. That objective is valid and important.

I believe a modern data protection law must also recognise that personal information is frequently essential to journalism.

The solution is not to exclude the media from responsibility. It is to create a defined statutory exemption that protects legitimate journalism while retaining safeguards against misuse.

I worry that without clarity news organisations may face uncertainty about the very activities through which they inform the public.

I think the absence of an exemption is therefore not merely a drafting issue. It is a question, about how India intends to balance privacy, responsibility and freedom of expression in the age.